Tua Tagovailoa Named Falcons' Week 1 Starter Over Michael Penix Jr.
A quarterback released by Miami this offseason gets a real second chance to start in Atlanta.
Tua Tagovailoa, released by Miami this offseason, was named the Falcons' Week 1 starting quarterback for the road opener at Pittsburgh — the team's 6th different Week 1 starter in 6 seasons — with Michael Penix Jr. inactive. It's a genuinely fresh start for a quarterback who spent his entire career to this point in Miami, now walking into a legitimately hostile road environment for his first snaps in a new uniform.
Useful next steps
Cooper Rush is the backup. Safety Jessie Bates III, who has dealt with a lingering back injury, is cleared to play, a real boost for an Atlanta secondary that needs its best defender available against a Pittsburgh offense that's added real weapons of its own this offseason.
Tagovailoa, 28, went a disappointing 6-8 as a starter in his final Miami season, completing 67.7% of his passes for 2,660 yards, 20 touchdowns, and a real career-high 15 interceptions before the Dolphins released him outright. Penix, 26, the No. 8 overall pick in the 2024 draft, is still genuinely working back from the torn ACL that ended his 2025 season early. Head coach Kevin Stefanski weighed the decision through the entire offseason, camp, and preseason before settling on Tagovailoa, who called the opportunity "very refreshing" and "a blessing," adding: "How I'm taking it is I got to go with this day-to-day and that's out of my control. What I can control is how I prepare, how I go out there, how I play, how I perform, and that's all I can do." Pittsburgh's own defenders admit some familiarity from facing Tagovailoa during his years with Miami, though they concede real uncertainty about what a new Atlanta offense actually asks him to do differently.
He will be terrible.— Jonathan Zaslow, NFL analyst, on Tagovailoa's Week 1 outlook
There's a chance they're going to cut him.— NFL insider, on Tagovailoa's real job security in Atlanta
Our take: giving Tagovailoa the job over a former top-10 pick who is still finishing a real ACL rehab makes sense in the short term, but the sixth different Week 1 starter in six years is its own kind of red flag for this franchise, not just a referendum on Tua. If this doesn't work fast, Atlanta has a real decision to make with Penix looming, and a road loss to a Steelers team many expect to contend for the AFC North would only accelerate that timeline.
Week 1 Prediction: Score, Spread & Player Prop
Steelers -3.5 home favorites (moneyline -185, Falcons +154), per multiple sportsbooks.
Total sits at 42.5, one of the week's lower totals. Our pick: Steelers 23, Falcons 17 (Under).
Tua Tagovailoa UNDER 1.5 passing touchdowns. A first start in a new offense against a real Pittsburgh defense fits the "ugly, low-scoring" shape analysts expect from this game.
Odds and props reflect market consensus across DraftKings, FanDuel, and BetMGM as of this week — lines move, so check your own sportsbook before kickoff.
Falcons' quarterback decision before Week 1
Miami releases Tua Tagovailoa; Atlanta signs him.
Tagovailoa named the Week 1 starter over Michael Penix Jr.
Falcons open on the road at Pittsburgh.
A real change at quarterback for the sixth straight year — Atlanta hopes this one is the answer.
Around the site
Sources: Washington Times, The Falcoholic, Pro Football Network